Who Should Lead Social Initiatives: CIOs or CMOs?

CIO
CMO
Ranendra Dutta

“Social media is forcing CIOs to learn a new set of skills and if that calls for the CIO to lead social initiatives, why should they cringe?”


Ranendra Dutta

SABMiller India, VP-IT

Amit Mukherjee

“Every business function in an organization is a niche function. That’s why social media should be led by the CMO.”


Amit Mukherjee

RPG Group, Group CIO

Marketing has conventionally been a CMO’s portfolio. But the very nature of social media platforms is technology-intensive and that’s why CIOs will be expected to provide their technical knowledge. The impact and vulnerability of this medium makes the role of the CIO all the more crucial. Businesses always look at IT to provide new channels of opportunities and that’s where CIOs transform into business strategists. Developing a social media platform doesn’t mean opening a Facebook page. It means analyzing and understanding the consumer’s makeup, widening interactive bridges and transforming all of this data into BI. Take our campaigns for example. Our brands Foster’s, Hayward’s, etcetera, have a great brand recall especially with the younger generation. When my marketing team was planning to execute a campaign for Foster’s, I proactively involved myself in it. We decided on a microblogging site linked to our Facebook page, Twitter account and website. It was my responsibility to explain to the marketing team how the site would be hosted, the advantages of open source and the legal complications around the online exchange of data. Today, the campaign has over 27,000 members and it’s my responsibility to ensure that the information out there is available to my marketing team for analysis of our products and market penetration. So, I feel that social media is forcing CIOs to learn yet another set of skills and if that calls for the CIO to lead innovation around social media initiatives in their organization, why should they cringe?

Whether the medium for marketing is print, electronic or new media, it should be left to the experts: CMOs. The involvement of a CIO in an organization’s social media is largely around providing the marketing team technical support. I doubt CIOs would be able to completely comprehend customer behavior or pick out purchasing patterns. But do CIOs even want to venture into the social media territory, given that their own job profiles are so humongous that they hardly get time for innovation within their own teams? In most organizations, driving social media content, and managing information flow and interaction is the marketing team’s responsibility. Based on the information that marketing teams desire, CIOs can only build systems. And that isn’t the same as leading social media initiatives. A person who leads a project is also accountable for the failure or success of that project. What if a marketing campaign whose content is not driven by the CIO, goes sour? Would it be fair to hold the CIO accountable? And if it is an IT driven project then who apart from the CIO will be held responsible? The volatile and viral nature of the medium is itself a cause of concern. Organizations need solid reliability and performance scores. Considering CIOs are on their toes 24/7 to just keep the lights on, isn’t that too much to ask for? Every business function in an organization is a niche function and has an expert designated to it. The CEOs, CFOs, CMOs, and the CIOs are all expected to work in tandem, bringing to the table their expertise in their respective fields. Infringing into a business colleague’s profile may also raise unwanted confrontations which are best avoided for the health of an organization. Of course, the CIO can collaborate with the CMO to derive out the best from a social media initiative but leading the project should be left to the CMO.

latest debates

Is Money the Best Way to Drive Employees?

Tarun Pandey
To rubbish the idea that employees don’t leave a job for money would be too impractical a statement to make. - Vijay SethiHero MotoCorp,VP & CIO
Tarun Pandey
Providing monetary benefits is an easier route to take but like most shortcuts, it’s not very effective. - Tarun PandeyAditya Birla Financial Services,VP-IT
vs